The NP001 formulation of sodium chlorite acts through a plausible mechanism and preliminary data suggest that it is safe and may slow ALS progression in some PALS. The WF10 formulation of SC appears to act through this same mechanism. Although WF10 is available for off-label use, it is very expensive, may have more side-effects than NP001, and at this time has only scant anecdotal evidence for efficacy in PALS. ALSUntangled supports further carefully monitored studies of NP001 and WF10 in PALS. In contrast, oral sodium chlorite has potentially dangerous and toxic side-effects may hasten disease progression, and is not clearly absorbed from the gut. We do not recommend further use of oral sodium chlorite unless it can at least be shown to be safe and to act on mechanisms in humans that are relevant to ALS.
Pre-clinical models (animal or cell models recognized by ALSUntangled reviewers to be relevant to ALS)
Azathioprine
As an immunosuppressant drug, AZA has a plausible mechanism for slowing the progression of ALS. However, there is no pre-clinical data to support its use and two clinical trials did not support efficacy. There are 2 published cases in which
ALS reversals occurred on AZA, but it is not clear to us that the AZA actually contributed to the ALS improvements. One of these patients also had myasthenia gravis, which is known to cause reversible weakness and therefore complicates the measurement of ALS. The other patient was taking many different medications and supplements along with AZA. AZA has very serious, potentially fatal, both short and long-term risks associated with its use and requires medical monitoring. Based on the
available data, we do not advise the use of AZA as an ALS treatment
Proprionyl-L-Carnitine
There are good theoretical mechanisms for carnitines, some pre-clinical evidence for LC and ALCAR, and a single clinical trial that suggested ALCAR could slow disease progression in PALS. All three carnitines appear to be well-tolerated, generally safe and inexpensive. We believe that there is a need for future clinical trials of carnitines in PALS to further elucidate their efficacy. Until there is further data, we cannot endorse any of these supplements as a definite way to slow ALS progression; however, oral ALCAR at 1000mg three times daily (3000 mg total daily dose) appears to be a theoretically promising supplement available for PALS whom would like to self-experiment.
LEAP2BFIT
Many ingredients contained within LEAP2BFIT could, at least in theory, be beneficial in ALS. Some of these ingredients have supporting animal or human studies. However, it is unknown if these ingredients are being provided in therapeutic quantities since the dosages are not disclosed. Furthermore, it is impossible to know the net positive or negative effect of so many ingredients without carefully testing the combination. Based on the above discussions, we do not currently recommend LEAP2BFIT as a way to slow, stop, or reverse ALS.
Vinpocetine
Vinpocetine has several plausible mechanisms by which it could slow ALS progression. There are two PALS online who reported improved motor functions on supplement cocktails containing Vinpocetine, but many other PALS have had no
benefits. Serious side effects from Vinpocetine are rare and it is inexpensive. We support further study of Vinpocetine in ALS, but our group was split on what the next step should be; some were in favor of a study in a pre-clinical ALS model and others were in favor of a small human trial to confirm its benefit on cramps (7) and to explore whether it is safe, tolerable and might slow disease progression.
Anti-fungals
It is unknown if fungi exist in the brain of PALS. If they do exist, it is unknown if they have any pathogenic effect, and unknown if antifungal drugs would modify ALS disease progression. There are no pre-clinical ALS model studies, verified ALS cases, or ALS clinical trials to suggest that antifungals would be of any significant benefit to PALS, and these medications can cause harm. At this time, we strongly discourage PALS from taking antifungal drugs for their ALS disease. We hope in the future that independent laboratories will look for fungi in the CNS of PALS using more appropriate experimental methods.
Click here to download the complete original review.
RCH4
RCH4 is an unlicensed, unapproved product reported to “probably slow the progression of your ALS” (6) on a website. The only peer reviewed publication we found on this product is a single abstract which was never presented at a meeting. We have been unable to determine RCH4’s structure or chemical class, and its purported mechanism is one that has never been shown to be useful in treating PALS before. We have been unable to independently verify RCH4’s reported efficacy or even safety. Thus, at this time, we cannot advise PALS to use this product. We hope the proponents of RCH4 will someday present more useful information about their product at a scientific meeting or in a peer reviewed publication.
We believe that regulatory oversight is important for optimizing patient safety on experimental drugs, and that independent peer review and replication are fundamentals of good science. Caution should be exercised around any product being developed and in clinical use without these safeguards and fundamentals in place.
Click here to download the complete review.
Penicillin G/Hydrocortisone
In our opinion, there is no convincing evidence that GABA overload plays a role in ALS progression. PNG/HC has other theoretical mechanisms by which it could slow ALS progression, but previous human trials involving steroids and a trial of a b lactam with more potent effects on glutamate did not help. We have not been able to confirm the diagnoses, nor the improvements described in the case series of 3 PALS taking PNG/HC; however, even if these treatment effects were real, these improvements were transient and quickly became unresponsive to treatment. Unless the ongoing placebo-controlled trial shows objective and sustained clinical improvements, we do not recommend that PALS take this expensive and risky combination of penicillin G and hydrocortisone.
Click here to download the complete review.